• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Home
  • What is LKP
  • Find everything …
  • Contact
Donate

Leasehold Knowledge Management Logo

Secretariat of the All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold reform

Mobile Menu

  • Home
  • What is LKP
  • Find everything …
  • Contact
  • Advice
  • News
    • Find everything …
    • About Peverel group
    • APPG
    • ARMA
    • Bellway
    • Benjamin Mire
    • Brixton Hill Court
    • Canary Riverside
    • Charter Quay
    • Chelsea Bridge Wharf
    • Cladding scandal
    • Competition and Markets Authority / OFT
    • Commonhold
    • Communities Select Committee
    • Conveyancing Association
    • Countrywide
    • MHCLG
    • E&J Capital Partners
    • Exit fees
    • FirstPort
    • Fleecehold
    • Forfeiture
    • FPRA
    • Gleeson Homes
    • Ground rent scandal
    • Hanover
    • House managers flat
    • House of Lords
    • Housing associations
    • Informal lease extension
    • Insurance
    • IRPM
    • JB Leitch
    • Jim Fitzpatrick MP
    • John Christodoulou
    • Justin Bates
    • Justin Madders MP
    • Law Commission
    • LEASE
    • Liam Spender
    • Local authority leasehold
    • London Assembly
    • Louie Burns
    • Martin Paine
    • McCarthy and Stone
    • Moskovitz / Gurvits
    • Mulberry Mews
    • National Leasehold Campaign
    • Oakland Court
    • Park Homes
    • Parliament
    • Persimmon
    • Peverel
    • Philip Rainey QC
    • Plantation Wharf
    • Press
    • Property tribunal
    • Prostitutes
    • Quadrangle House
    • Redrow
    • Retirement
    • Richard Davidoff
    • RICS
    • Right To Manage Federation
    • Roger Southam
    • Rooftop development
    • RTM
    • Sean Powell
    • SFO
    • Shared ownership
    • Sinclair Gardens Investments
    • Sir Ed Davey
    • Sir Peter Bottomley
    • St George’s Wharf
    • Subletting
    • Taylor Wimpey
    • Tchenguiz
    • Warwick Estates
    • West India Quay
    • William Waldorf Astor
    • Windrush Court
  • Parliament
  • Accreditation
  • [Custom]
Menu
  • Advice
  • News
      • Find everything …
      • About Peverel group
      • APPG
      • ARMA
      • Bellway
      • Benjamin Mire
      • Brixton Hill Court
      • Canary Riverside
      • Charter Quay
      • Chelsea Bridge Wharf
      • Cladding scandal
      • Competition and Markets Authority / OFT
      • Commonhold
      • Communities Select Committee
      • Conveyancing Association
      • Countrywide
      • MHCLG
      • E&J Capital Partners
      • Exit fees
      • FirstPort
      • Fleecehold
      • Forfeiture
      • FPRA
      • Gleeson Homes
      • Ground rent scandal
      • Hanover
      • House managers flat
      • House of Lords
      • Housing associations
      • Informal lease extension
      • Insurance
      • IRPM
      • JB Leitch
      • Jim Fitzpatrick MP
      • John Christodoulou
      • Justin Bates
      • Justin Madders MP
      • Law Commission
      • LEASE
      • Liam Spender
      • Local authority leasehold
      • London Assembly
      • Louie Burns
      • Martin Paine
      • McCarthy and Stone
      • Moskovitz / Gurvits
      • Mulberry Mews
      • National Leasehold Campaign
      • Oakland Court
      • Park Homes
      • Parliament
      • Persimmon
      • Peverel
      • Philip Rainey QC
      • Plantation Wharf
      • Press
      • Property tribunal
      • Prostitutes
      • Quadrangle House
      • Redrow
      • Retirement
      • Richard Davidoff
      • RICS
      • Right To Manage Federation
      • Roger Southam
      • Rooftop development
      • RTM
      • Sean Powell
      • SFO
      • Shared ownership
      • Sinclair Gardens Investments
      • Sir Ed Davey
      • Sir Peter Bottomley
      • St George’s Wharf
      • Subletting
      • Taylor Wimpey
      • Tchenguiz
      • Warwick Estates
      • West India Quay
      • William Waldorf Astor
      • Windrush Court
  • Parliament
  • Accreditation
You are here: Home / News / Gurvits / Bottomley meets Joseph Gurvits and Israel Moskovitz over leasehold right to manage disputes at Plymouth retirement developments – but residents are determined to fight it out

Bottomley meets Joseph Gurvits and Israel Moskovitz over leasehold right to manage disputes at Plymouth retirement developments – but residents are determined to fight it out

February 1, 2013 //  by Sebastian O'Kelly

BottomleySir Peter Bottomley MP (right) held a meeting yesterday at his Westminster offices with the freeholder and managing agent who are locked in right to manage disputes with leaseholders at two Plymouth retirement developments.

The meeting was an informal exchange of views between freeholder Israel Moskovitz, property manager Joseph Gurvits and Sebastian O’Kelly and Martin Boyd of the Leasehold Knowledge Partnership. The meeting was also attended by Sophie Hutchinson, parliamentary research assistant of Oliver Colvile, the pensioners’ MP, and Elena Andreadis, property manager for the sites.

Earlier this month Elim Court lost its third attempt at exercising its right to manage against Mr Moskovitz’s Avon Freeholds at the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal owing to errors in the paperwork. Regent Court obtained right to manage in February last year, but the issue is being appealed at the Land Tribunal in April.

An additional cause for ill-feeling at Regent Court is that the roof was irreparably damaged in a storm in April 2012, but was found to be at the end of its practical life and therefore not covered under the insurance.

The insurance company, AXA, did offer to pay 50 per cent of the repair at one point and then decided that nothing was owed.

As a result, all the residents – bar the estates of three – paid up £140,000 on January 25.

Sir Peter Bottomley, who named Joseph Gurvits in the Commons on January 23, made it clear that the issues surrounding the two sites were not going to disappear from public view and that it would be better all round if they were resolved.

In particular, he was of the view that if leaseholders want right to manage, organise for it and presented their case they should not be frustrated by legal quibbling at the LVT. “The fact that that can be done does not make it right,” he said.

He was aware of a number of complaints from leaseholders in different properties around London managed by the Gurvits family’s Eagerstates “and they did not make good reading”.

Sir Peter said that he was aware of 40-odd MPs with an interest in leasehold who could be relied upon to take leasehold issues up. He also indicated that he would speak out publicly against those who play the system against leaseholders.

Regent and Elim Courts had been raised with the Housing Minister Mark Prisk, and Oliver Colvile, the local MP, who is visiting the sites tomorrow.

Both Regent and Elim Court right to manage actions have been opposed by barristers employed by Mr Moskovitz. His costs for fighting the Elim case total £12,688, which Elena Andreadis sent to residents on January 16.

Mr Moskovitz indicated that similar costs were involved disputing the RTM at Regent Court.

Mr Moskovitz said that he had to protect his “reversionary interest” – the freehold, its income and it eventually owning the whole building in 70 years time – and so opposed right to manage. He subsequently indicated that he had no objection in principle to the pensioners obtaining right to manage.

Both he and Mr Gurvits were indignant that the right to manage actions at both sites had been instigated, they believed, by the Right To Manage Federation, an RTM agency that levies a fee from the newly appointed incoming managing agent. They appeared to view the organisation as simply a commercial rival.

They also believed – wrongly – that Campaign against retirement leasehold exploitation had some connection with the RTMF and its proprietor, Dudley Joiner, which is not the case. Mr Joiner and Campaign against retirement leasehold exploitation did organise several meetings more than two years ago, but the connection ended.

Mr Moskovitz and Mr Gurvits also criticised the coverage of Elim and Regent Courts on the Campaign against retirement leasehold exploitation websites, which they believed were “too personal”.

Mr Moskovitz said that he would be happy to sell the freehold, but estimated its value at more than £300,000 and doubted whether the pensioners would be able to afford it. [He is understood to have bought the freehold two years for circa £180,000.]

Mr Moskovitz made clear that he employed Mr Gurvits in Y and Y Management, but had no involvement with Eagerstates, a property management company familiar to London leaseholders run, Mr Gurvits explained, by his wife, Esther.

Mr Moskovitz emphasised that he was a man of moral integrity, who was involved in charities and had not wrongly taken any money from the pensioners. They had been treated with scrupulous honesty and Elena Aleandris, of Y and Y Management, was an excellent and conscientious property manager.

Miss Aleandris, a former solicitor, believed that pensioners at the site had been  “harassed” into signing up for the right to manage actions, with peer group pressure and RTM canvassers knocking on residents’ doors. She said eight residents at Elim Court had changed their minds about right to mange.

She visited the sites four times a year and was deeply concerned with the pensioners’ welfare, she said.

Mr Moskovits would contact the insurance company AXA to allow Mr Colvile to discover why it declined to pay out on the roof at Regent Court. At one point last summer it did offer to pay 50 per cent of the replacement roof, and then decided that nothing was owed because the roof’s condition meant it was at the end of its useful life.

But the prospect of the right to manage actions being resolved without further expensive litigation became less likely yesterday following a residents’ meeting at Elim Court.

The residents, who were addressed by Mr Joiner, of the Right To Manage Federation, resolved to appeal the right to manage defeat of January. His hope is to have both the Elim and Regent Court appeals held at the same time in April.

Mr Joiner has repeatedly told the residents – and Campaign against retirement leasehold exploitation – that the legal costs involved in these actions will be borne by his organisation.

However, the legal liability remains that of the leaseholders.

Mr Moskovitz estimated his costs against the Regent Court RTM are only slightly lower than those of Elim. If both issues go to the Land Tribunal Mr Moskovitz’s estimate of costs will almost certainly exceed £30,000.

Mr Colvile is meeting residents at Elim and Regent Court tomorrow where he will be told that there is overwhelming support for right to manage at both sites.

The residents also propose to ask whether Mr Colvile, as their MP, will approach the Bar Council pro bono unit to provide a barrister at no cost.

Related posts:

Default ThumbnailTory MP backs pensioners in leasehold right to manage dispute Israel Moskovitz fails – again – to appeal against the Regent Court right to manage Default ThumbnailManaging agent Joseph Gurvits named in Commons – an hour after MP attends ARMA round-table conference on tougher ethical standards Tribunal tells freeholder Israel Moskovitz to drop the ‘nonsense’ to frustrate right to manage Israel Moskovitz loses epic Elim Court right to manage battle in landmark Court of Appeal decision

Category: Gurvits, Israel Moskovitz, Moskovitz / Gurvits, News, Retirement, Sir Peter BottomleyTag: Elena Andreadis, Elim Court, Israel Moskovitz, Joseph Gurvits, Martin Boyd, Regent Court, Retirement, Sebastian O’Kelly, Sir Peter Bottomley, Y and Y Management

Latest Tweets

Tweets by @LKPleasehold

Mentions

Anthony Essien (34) APPG (37) ARMA (87) Bellway (30) Benjamin Mire (32) Cladding scandal (71) Clive Betts MP (31) CMA (45) Commonhold (52) Competition and Markets Authority (41) Countryside Properties plc (33) FirstPort (42) Grenfell cladding (56) Ground rents (54) Harry Scoffin (150) James Brokenshire MP (31) Jim Fitzpatrick (35) Jim Fitzpatrick MP (30) Justin Bates (40) Justin Madders MP (67) Katie Kendrick (37) Law Commission (60) LEASE (66) Leasehold Advisory Service (62) Leasehold houses (32) Long Harbour (48) Martin Boyd (80) McCarthy and Stone (39) National Leasehold Campaign (38) Persimmon (49) Peverel (61) Property tribunal (49) Redrow (30) Retirement (37) Robert Jenrick (33) Roger Southam (47) Sajid Javid (38) Sebastian O’Kelly (55) Sir Peter Bottomley (201) Taylor Wimpey (106) Tchenguiz (33) The Guardian (33) The Times (31) Vincent Tchenguiz (43) Waking watch contracts (40)
Previous Post: « Managing agent Joseph Gurvits named in Commons – an hour after MP attends ARMA round-table conference on tougher ethical standards
Next Post: Islington leasehold dispute costs £300,000 in overcharging »

Above Footer

Advising leaseholders. Avoiding disasters.
Stopping forfeiture. Exposing abuses. Urging reform.

We depend on individuals for the majority of our funding.

Support Us and Donate

LKP Managing Agents

Become an LKP Managing Agent

Common Ground
Adam Church
Blocnet property management2

Stay in Touch

To achieve victory in the leasehold game where you are playing against professionals and with rules that they know all too well - stay informed with the LKP newsletter.
Sign Up for Newsletter

Professional Directory

The following advertisements are from firms that seek business from leaseholders.
Click on the logos for company profiles.

Footer

About LKP

  • What is LKP
  • Privacy and data

Categories

  • News
  • Cladding scandal
  • Commonhold
  • Law Commission
  • Fleecehold
  • Parliament
  • Press
  • APPG

Contact

Leasehold Knowledge Partnership
Open Data Institute
5th Floor
Kings Place
London N1 9AG

sok@leaseholdknowledge.com

Copyright © 2023 Leasehold Knowledge Partnership | All rights reserved
Leasehold Knowledge Partnership Limited (company number: 08999652) is a company limited by guarantee that is a registered charity (number: 1162584) with the Charities Commission.
LKP website is hosted at www.34sp.com
Website by Callia Web