• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Home
  • What is LKP
  • Find everything …
  • Contact
Donate

Leasehold Knowledge Management Logo

Secretariat of the All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold reform

Mobile Menu

  • Home
  • What is LKP
  • Find everything …
  • Contact
  • Advice
  • News
    • Find everything …
    • About Peverel group
    • APPG
    • ARMA
    • Bellway
    • Benjamin Mire
    • Brixton Hill Court
    • Canary Riverside
    • Charter Quay
    • Chelsea Bridge Wharf
    • Cladding scandal
    • Competition and Markets Authority / OFT
    • Commonhold
    • Communities Select Committee
    • Conveyancing Association
    • Countrywide
    • MHCLG
    • E&J Capital Partners
    • Exit fees
    • FirstPort
    • Fleecehold
    • Forfeiture
    • FPRA
    • Gleeson Homes
    • Ground rent scandal
    • Hanover
    • House managers flat
    • House of Lords
    • Housing associations
    • Informal lease extension
    • Insurance
    • IRPM
    • JB Leitch
    • Jim Fitzpatrick MP
    • John Christodoulou
    • Justin Bates
    • Justin Madders MP
    • Law Commission
    • LEASE
    • Liam Spender
    • Local authority leasehold
    • London Assembly
    • Louie Burns
    • Martin Paine
    • McCarthy and Stone
    • Moskovitz / Gurvits
    • Mulberry Mews
    • National Leasehold Campaign
    • Oakland Court
    • Park Homes
    • Parliament
    • Persimmon
    • Peverel
    • Philip Rainey QC
    • Plantation Wharf
    • Press
    • Property tribunal
    • Prostitutes
    • Quadrangle House
    • Redrow
    • Retirement
    • Richard Davidoff
    • RICS
    • Right To Manage Federation
    • Roger Southam
    • Rooftop development
    • RTM
    • Sean Powell
    • SFO
    • Shared ownership
    • Sinclair Gardens Investments
    • Sir Ed Davey
    • Sir Peter Bottomley
    • St George’s Wharf
    • Subletting
    • Taylor Wimpey
    • Tchenguiz
    • Warwick Estates
    • West India Quay
    • William Waldorf Astor
    • Windrush Court
  • Parliament
  • Accreditation
  • [Custom]
Menu
  • Advice
  • News
      • Find everything …
      • About Peverel group
      • APPG
      • ARMA
      • Bellway
      • Benjamin Mire
      • Brixton Hill Court
      • Canary Riverside
      • Charter Quay
      • Chelsea Bridge Wharf
      • Cladding scandal
      • Competition and Markets Authority / OFT
      • Commonhold
      • Communities Select Committee
      • Conveyancing Association
      • Countrywide
      • MHCLG
      • E&J Capital Partners
      • Exit fees
      • FirstPort
      • Fleecehold
      • Forfeiture
      • FPRA
      • Gleeson Homes
      • Ground rent scandal
      • Hanover
      • House managers flat
      • House of Lords
      • Housing associations
      • Informal lease extension
      • Insurance
      • IRPM
      • JB Leitch
      • Jim Fitzpatrick MP
      • John Christodoulou
      • Justin Bates
      • Justin Madders MP
      • Law Commission
      • LEASE
      • Liam Spender
      • Local authority leasehold
      • London Assembly
      • Louie Burns
      • Martin Paine
      • McCarthy and Stone
      • Moskovitz / Gurvits
      • Mulberry Mews
      • National Leasehold Campaign
      • Oakland Court
      • Park Homes
      • Parliament
      • Persimmon
      • Peverel
      • Philip Rainey QC
      • Plantation Wharf
      • Press
      • Property tribunal
      • Prostitutes
      • Quadrangle House
      • Redrow
      • Retirement
      • Richard Davidoff
      • RICS
      • Right To Manage Federation
      • Roger Southam
      • Rooftop development
      • RTM
      • Sean Powell
      • SFO
      • Shared ownership
      • Sinclair Gardens Investments
      • Sir Ed Davey
      • Sir Peter Bottomley
      • St George’s Wharf
      • Subletting
      • Taylor Wimpey
      • Tchenguiz
      • Warwick Estates
      • West India Quay
      • William Waldorf Astor
      • Windrush Court
  • Parliament
  • Accreditation
You are here: Home / News / Lords from all parties trash government’s multi-billion pound give-away to freehold owners

Lords from all parties trash government’s multi-billion pound give-away to freehold owners

September 11, 2020 //  by Admin4

And Sir Ed Davey signs up to Sir Kier Starmer’s criticism of the move

Baroness (Kay) Andrews, a former Labour housing minister, praised “the very authoritative Leasehold Knowledge Partnership” for revealing “the scale of profit potential for developers … to be between £20 billion and £40 billion” from the government’s two-storey give-away to freeholders, who are so often anonymous and based offshore

By Harry Scoffin

Members of the House of Lords have rounded on the government’s two-storey planning give-away to freehold owners of blocks of flats.

Baroness (Kay) Andrews, a former Labour housing minister, praised “the very authoritative Leasehold Knowledge Partnership” for “reveal[ing] the scale of profit potential for developers … to be between £20 billion and £40 billion”.

The overwhelmingly negative response of the Lords to the permitted development give-away has been echoed by Liberal Democrat leader and LKP patron Sir Ed Davey.

He has signed Sir Keir Starmer’s early day motion condemning the move and encouraged all other Lib Dems to do the same – including Alastair Carmichael, MP for Shetland and Okney Islands (which do not have many flats and no English leasehold tenure either). The government needs to sort out the leasehold and cladding scandals “rather than tearing up planning laws”, said Sir Ed.

Leader of the Liberal Democrats Ed Davey said:

“A solution to this scandal is long overdue. Yet the Tories seem happy to allow homeowners to be trapped in their homes due to this exploitative practice, leaving them with no choice but to continue paying or sell at a considerable loss.

“Liberal Democrats believe that if the Tories want to build more homes as they say, they should fix the real problems with the housing market, rather than tearing up planning laws.”

This means 50 MPs have now signed Sir Kier’s EDM, which was initiated by Conservative MP and LKP patron Sir Peter Bottomley.

42 MPs back Starmer’s attempt to block rooftop planning give-away to freeholders 

LKP analysis of the government’s own impact assessment shows that over 1.8 million leaseholders in the freestanding purpose-built blocks, which must have been built between 1948 and 2018 and be of less than 30 metres in height and over 3 storeys to qualify for the new upwards extensions process, will lose out with the cost of freehold purchase increasing by between £11,000 and £28,000 per flat.

Baroness Andrews declared that she is one of the 1.8 million leaseholders affected by the policy, with her freehold owner already rushing to capitalise on the rule change.

She told the Lords in the debate on Thursday:

“This SI [statutory instrument] will guarantee uncontrolled profits for developers who are looking around at the scale of building in the centre of London, for example, thinking “I want some of the action” and taking opportunities to do just that. It will also damage the prospects and well-being of residents of existing residential blocks of flats who in different ways will be put at serious risk by this …”

She added:

“We have not been consulted; we do not want it; it is unpredictable and problematic in terms of buildability, safety and loss of amenity. We may well be faced with a choice between living in a building site—ceilings coming down and holes in the walls—or evacuating, and there is no compensation for the loss of peaceful enjoyment. 

“There will be resort to law, but only for people who can afford it.

“The Government knew from the start that this was an unpopular policy … and many of the issues raised were completely ignored.”

She urged the government to opt for an early review of the policy rather than waiting the normal five years.

She concluded:

“Will the [housing minister Lord Greenhalgh] also seize the opportunity presented by the Law Commission to accelerate the reforms in leaseholding and look for ways to restrain the colossal prospects of developers? It is an unfair, unbalanced and inefficient policy, but we have a chance to do something about it.”

Lord German, a former leader of the Welsh Lib Dems, said the sudden planning give-away was “the perfect example of a major policy change being side-slipped through Parliament” under cover of the coronavirus crisis to minimise parliamentary scrutiny.

Lord German added that when the government originally put the rooftop development proposals out to public consultation, the majority of responses were overwhelmingly negative.

With the planning consultation process “a shadow of what currently exists”, Lord German noted that the prior approval notice will be served on leaseholders “within a very tight timetable”. Objections will “only be considered if they relate to the dual issues of amenity and external appearance”.

Lord German opened for the Lib Dems

He argued the new policy has failed to consider substantive issues such as how the influx of additional occupiers will affect access to the property; whether a lift would be needed and where it could be placed; and the requirements on the freehold owner to prevent added pressure to the service charges of the existing leaseholders.

The building work would inevitably be disruptive, said Lord German.

“Residents would turn to their council and their councillors to express their concerns – and they would find them powerless.”

Lord German ended by saying that the planning give-away “indicate a Government making a dramatic shift away from strong and caring communities, with local councils as their facilitators, towards the aspirations of developers and a distant Government”.

Labour peer Baroness Wilcox, a former council leader, demanded the government “look for ways of restraining developers’ profits, so that opportunist developers have less ability to make life worse for our communities”.

Lib Dem Lord Greaves described the two-storey permitted development right as “silly nonsense”.

Chartered surveyor Lord Thurlow, a crossbench peer and member of the APPG on leasehold and commonhold reform, warned last month that the permitted development reform would lead to another “tidal wave of protest and complaint” on the scale of the ground rents scandal.

Lord Thurlow made an appearance via video link to repeat the human and social costs of the planning deregulation. He urged ministers to use forthcoming business and planning legislation to rectify the worst elements of the policy

He tolds the Lords yesterday that the government has had two years of evidence of the disastrous impact that a similar relaxing of planning rules on office-to-residential conversions has caused.

“In short, the provision of some of the worst housing seen in Britain for decades came through … crushingly small flats lacking adequate daylight, with windows out of position for suitable residential use, designed to squeeze the maximum number of bed-sits into a given floor area, cramming in as many rent payers as possible with little regard for the quality of life, mental health or general well-being of the people there,” he said.

“Many landlords will negotiate with their tenants—they are the responsible ones. Others will not. It is likely to become a minefield of legislation and only a small percentage of tenants will be able to afford it. There is no regulation of landlords, no minimum standards and no best practice of building management.”

He also suggested the rule change would empower the very worst speculators in residential freeholds to cram new flats into a block as a way of extracting more service charges. “The image of a modern Rachman comes to mind.”

The former leader of the Welsh Conservatives called for ‘additional rights for leaseholders being brought forward in fresh legislation’

Former Welsh Tory leader Lord Bourne, who spoke alongside Lord Thurlow last month in the chamber to criticise the “windfall” given to freehold owners by the two-storey PD right, joined in to query why the permanent reform was bundled together with emergency coronavirus regulations.

A professor of law, Lord Bourne also said leaseholders looked to be “short-changed” as they were “not really considered in this legislation as they should be” in terms of their rights, particularly with regards to collective enfranchisement.

He praised LKP joint patron / APPG co-chair Sir Peter Bottomley for drawing the attention of the Commons to the issue.

Responding for the government, Lord Greenhalgh said the measure had been introduced under the coronavirus heading to both “kick-start the economy” and make the “most efficient use” of the statutory instrument procedure, which has been criticised for subverting the legislature’s role in scrutinising the executive.

Lord Greenhalgh also claimed that the Law Commission’s recommendations on reducing the price payable would also apply to leaseholders in buildings where the freehold owner can impose two extra storeys. 

Related posts:

Lords warn government of “tidal wave of protest” at new right for freeholders to add extra floors without permission Sir Peter Bottomley furiousMPs fail to stop Robert Jenrick’s multi-billion pound planning hand-out to offshore freeholders 42 MPs back Starmer’s attempt to block rooftop planning give-away to freeholders  Two-storey planning give-awayTory councillors and Labour MP back leaseholders in blocking ERE freeholds shoving up two more storeys under Jenrick’s planning give-away Lobbying alert: Theresa Villiers MP speaks up for ground rents, freehold owners and making sure marriage value still pays off for freehold investors

Category: Advice Case Study Disasters, Latest News, News, Parliament, Rooftop developmentTag: Baroness Andrews, Baroness Wilcox, Harry Scoffin, Lord Bourne, Lord German, Lord Greaves, Lord Greenhalgh, Lord Thurlow, Permitted development, Rooftop development, Sir Ed Davey, Sir Keir Starmer, Sir Peter Bottomley

Latest Tweets

Tweets by @LKPleasehold

Mentions

Anthony Essien (34) APPG (37) ARMA (87) Bellway (30) Benjamin Mire (32) Cladding scandal (71) Clive Betts MP (31) CMA (45) Commonhold (52) Competition and Markets Authority (41) Countryside Properties plc (33) FirstPort (42) Grenfell cladding (56) Ground rents (54) Harry Scoffin (150) James Brokenshire MP (31) Jim Fitzpatrick (35) Jim Fitzpatrick MP (30) Justin Bates (40) Justin Madders MP (67) Katie Kendrick (37) Law Commission (60) LEASE (66) Leasehold Advisory Service (62) Leasehold houses (32) Long Harbour (48) Martin Boyd (80) McCarthy and Stone (39) National Leasehold Campaign (38) Persimmon (49) Peverel (61) Property tribunal (49) Redrow (30) Retirement (37) Robert Jenrick (33) Roger Southam (47) Sajid Javid (38) Sebastian O’Kelly (55) Sir Peter Bottomley (201) Taylor Wimpey (106) Tchenguiz (33) The Guardian (33) The Times (31) Vincent Tchenguiz (43) Waking watch contracts (40)
Previous Post: «Building Safety Bill URGENT: Respond to Building Safety Bill call for evidence
Next Post: ‘Everybody must call on government, whoever you vote for’ to resolve cladding crisis, says Starmer »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Di.

    September 12, 2020 at 4:13 pm

    Thanks Boris and company, we know where we stand now…. we know which side you are on… you are not with the plebs that put you in power.

    D.Rigg

  2. terry sullivan

    September 24, 2020 at 12:48 pm

    boris is on boris’s side–and his fathers?

    lords has no power

Above Footer

Advising leaseholders. Avoiding disasters.
Stopping forfeiture. Exposing abuses. Urging reform.

We depend on individuals for the majority of our funding.

Support Us and Donate

LKP Managing Agents

Become an LKP Managing Agent

Common Ground
Adam Church
Blocnet property management2

Stay in Touch

To achieve victory in the leasehold game where you are playing against professionals and with rules that they know all too well - stay informed with the LKP newsletter.
Sign Up for Newsletter

Professional Directory

The following advertisements are from firms that seek business from leaseholders.
Click on the logos for company profiles.

Footer

About LKP

  • What is LKP
  • Privacy and data

Categories

  • News
  • Cladding scandal
  • Commonhold
  • Law Commission
  • Fleecehold
  • Parliament
  • Press
  • APPG

Contact

Leasehold Knowledge Partnership
Open Data Institute
5th Floor
Kings Place
London N1 9AG

sok@leaseholdknowledge.com

Copyright © 2023 Leasehold Knowledge Partnership | All rights reserved
Leasehold Knowledge Partnership Limited (company number: 08999652) is a company limited by guarantee that is a registered charity (number: 1162584) with the Charities Commission.
LKP website is hosted at www.34sp.com
Website by Callia Web