• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Home
  • What is LKP
  • Find everything …
  • Contact
Donate

Leasehold Knowledge Management Logo

Secretariat of the All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold reform

Mobile Menu

  • Home
  • What is LKP
  • Find everything …
  • Contact
  • Advice
  • News
    • Find everything …
    • About Peverel group
    • APPG
    • ARMA
    • Bellway
    • Benjamin Mire
    • Brixton Hill Court
    • Canary Riverside
    • Charter Quay
    • Chelsea Bridge Wharf
    • Cladding scandal
    • Competition and Markets Authority / OFT
    • Commonhold
    • Communities Select Committee
    • Conveyancing Association
    • Countrywide
    • MHCLG
    • E&J Capital Partners
    • Exit fees
    • FirstPort
    • Fleecehold
    • Forfeiture
    • FPRA
    • Gleeson Homes
    • Ground rent scandal
    • Hanover
    • House managers flat
    • House of Lords
    • Housing associations
    • Informal lease extension
    • Insurance
    • IRPM
    • JB Leitch
    • Jim Fitzpatrick MP
    • John Christodoulou
    • Justin Bates
    • Justin Madders MP
    • Law Commission
    • LEASE
    • Liam Spender
    • Local authority leasehold
    • London Assembly
    • Louie Burns
    • Martin Paine
    • McCarthy and Stone
    • Moskovitz / Gurvits
    • Mulberry Mews
    • National Leasehold Campaign
    • Oakland Court
    • Park Homes
    • Parliament
    • Persimmon
    • Peverel
    • Philip Rainey QC
    • Plantation Wharf
    • Press
    • Property tribunal
    • Prostitutes
    • Quadrangle House
    • Redrow
    • Retirement
    • Richard Davidoff
    • RICS
    • Right To Manage Federation
    • Roger Southam
    • Rooftop development
    • RTM
    • Sean Powell
    • SFO
    • Shared ownership
    • Sinclair Gardens Investments
    • Sir Ed Davey
    • Sir Peter Bottomley
    • St George’s Wharf
    • Subletting
    • Taylor Wimpey
    • Tchenguiz
    • Warwick Estates
    • West India Quay
    • William Waldorf Astor
    • Windrush Court
  • Parliament
  • Accreditation
  • [Custom]
Menu
  • Advice
  • News
      • Find everything …
      • About Peverel group
      • APPG
      • ARMA
      • Bellway
      • Benjamin Mire
      • Brixton Hill Court
      • Canary Riverside
      • Charter Quay
      • Chelsea Bridge Wharf
      • Cladding scandal
      • Competition and Markets Authority / OFT
      • Commonhold
      • Communities Select Committee
      • Conveyancing Association
      • Countrywide
      • MHCLG
      • E&J Capital Partners
      • Exit fees
      • FirstPort
      • Fleecehold
      • Forfeiture
      • FPRA
      • Gleeson Homes
      • Ground rent scandal
      • Hanover
      • House managers flat
      • House of Lords
      • Housing associations
      • Informal lease extension
      • Insurance
      • IRPM
      • JB Leitch
      • Jim Fitzpatrick MP
      • John Christodoulou
      • Justin Bates
      • Justin Madders MP
      • Law Commission
      • LEASE
      • Liam Spender
      • Local authority leasehold
      • London Assembly
      • Louie Burns
      • Martin Paine
      • McCarthy and Stone
      • Moskovitz / Gurvits
      • Mulberry Mews
      • National Leasehold Campaign
      • Oakland Court
      • Park Homes
      • Parliament
      • Persimmon
      • Peverel
      • Philip Rainey QC
      • Plantation Wharf
      • Press
      • Property tribunal
      • Prostitutes
      • Quadrangle House
      • Redrow
      • Retirement
      • Richard Davidoff
      • RICS
      • Right To Manage Federation
      • Roger Southam
      • Rooftop development
      • RTM
      • Sean Powell
      • SFO
      • Shared ownership
      • Sinclair Gardens Investments
      • Sir Ed Davey
      • Sir Peter Bottomley
      • St George’s Wharf
      • Subletting
      • Taylor Wimpey
      • Tchenguiz
      • Warwick Estates
      • West India Quay
      • William Waldorf Astor
      • Windrush Court
  • Parliament
  • Accreditation
You are here: Home / News / Forfeiture / George Osborne’s former nanny faces £100,000 bills and loss of home

George Osborne’s former nanny faces £100,000 bills and loss of home

February 4, 2014 //  by Sebastian O'Kelly

Farieda Chandoo challenged Southwarl's £40,000 repair bill, but has ended up with legal bills and other costs that exceed £100,000
Farieda Chandoo challenged Southwark’s £40,000 repair bill, but has ended up with legal bills and other costs that exceed £100,000

The issues in this case – and others concerning local authority leasehold – will be debated tomorrow morning on BBC Five Live with Eric Pickles,  Communities Secretary, and Sebastian O’Kelly, of LKP, at 11.30am, Sunday January 12

Farieda Cgandoo, 60, on the balcony at her council-owned block in south London, where she has been a leaseholder of a three-bedroom, split-level flat since 1997. After her disastrous legal battles with Southwark council, she is almost certainly going to have to sell
Farieda Chandoo, 60, on the balcony at her council-owned block in south London, where she has been a leaseholder of a three-bedroom, split-level flat since 1997. After her disastrous legal battles with Southwark council, she is almost certainly going to have to sell

A disastrous act of defiance in refusing to pay her share of a council’s major works scheme has cost Farieda Chandoo, 60, – who once looked after the five-year-old George Osborne – nearly £100,000.

She will also almost certainly have to sell her three-bedroom, split-level former council flat after being bailed out by her mortgage lenders.

Farieda, who was born in Trinidad, bought her comfortable flat in a 1970s three-storey block for £42,000 in 1997 from the former council tenant who had exercised the right to buy.

But she refused to accept that a £3.8 million refurbishment of the Brandon Estate, between Camberwell and the Oval, was necessary and believed the works to have been appallingly carried out. Her block, Kirwyn Way, had to pay £1.1 million.

As a result, she withheld payment of £40,000, which was her share for the works, setting in train a series of disasters which resulted in her facing a four-day forfeiture hearing at the county court last month (December 10 2013).

She now faces a total bill of nearly £100,000, and it could be more once the cost of the mortgage lender’s bail out is added to the total. The flat itself is only valued at £195,000.

“At one point I even got in touch with George Osborne’s mother through their business address,” says Farieda. “I hated to do it as it was like putting out the begging bowl.

“George was a lovely little boy and I was very fond of the family. But I never heard anything back. It was a long time ago.”

As she has always been in full-time employment as an NHS secretary, Farieda was the only leaseholder in Kirwyn Way who paid the full amount.

“I have always paid my service charge and I do not expect something for nothing,” says Farieda. “But I just will not pay for things that I did not receive.

“These works were badly carried out and made my life worse rather than improved it, so I refused to pay and fought the council in the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal.”

That took place in January 2011 and Farieda, who spent £500 on legal preparation for the case, was yet another lay applicant leaseholder to fail to persuade a tribunal when up against a legally represented freeholder.

In this case, however, and in contrast to so many private freeholders who use legal costs to play the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal system, Southwark did not ask for its legal costs at all.

Farieda demonstrates broken masonry, which as refurbished four years ago
Farieda demonstrates broken masonry, which as refurbished four years ago

Farieda’s argument was that the costs for council leaseholders should be capped at £10,000 – something which Eric Pickles, the Communities Secretary, is keen to introduce, although the figure will be higher in London at £15,000.

She also produced a string of complaints about the works, most of which were rejected.

But the builders did put a hole in the roof causing a leak to her flat. In addition, a front porch was erected which the tribunal ruled was not refurbishment, but new works, and the cost was removed from Farieda’s bill.

Nonetheless, on almost all points her arguments failed.

The tribunal ruled:

“This is yet another case of a leaseholder who has purchased a right to buy property from the original purchaser at the full market price, believed the property to be in good or at least acceptable condition and is then confronted with a bill for major works for over £38,000 which she is unable to afford and which had been imposed upon here by the landlord’s implementation of the Government’s Decent Homes Initiative.”

As well as considering the sum unjust, Farieda was  simply unable to pay it, although Southwark does run a low interest loan scheme for council leaseholders in these positions. “But I could not afford to pay £600 a month more,” said Farieda. She also refused to accept that she needed to.

She continued to dispute the amount, spending £13,000 on a solicitor and £2,000 on a surveyor to examine the works at Kirwyn Way.

Nonetheless, she was without any professional representation at the four-day county court hearing that started on December 10.

Why a forfeiture hearing should be assigned four days is a question that requires an answer, but Farieda was unshakeable in her belief that she could re-fight the battle lost in the LVT and assembled her arguments according.

LKP, which was contacted before the case, urged dialogue with the council to avoid a further avalanche of costs for the legal profession – and the charges of Farieda’s mortgage lender.

The result of the four-day hearing has been an utter disaster.

On this occasion, Southwark deployed a barrister and sought and obtained £24,000 in costs.

“I will have to sell my flat because of this and I have no idea what I will do,” she says. “I will have to move into some bedsit somewhere. This case has brought me utter ruin.”

Water floods the gutters and gathers on the balconies of the top floor. There have been complaints of damp by residents below
Water floods the gutters and gathers on the balconies of the top floor. There have been complaints of damp by residents below

How she has managed to carry out a full-time job in the face of this litigation is astonishing.

What can be done to stop more cases like Farieda Chandoo’s?

It is a failure all round that this case came to court and that a dignified, independent woman is almost certainly going to have to sell her home and go into rented accommodation.

It is an open question why the judiciary permitted a four-day forfeiture hearing with a lay applicant.

Forfeiture can be lifted in 10-minute hearings where mortgage lenders agree – as they usually do – to pay the outstanding debt.

If there was no chance of Farieda interesting the court in her complaints about the necessity and quality of the works at Kirwyn Way, then one has to ask whose interests were served by holding a protracted case.

When she was first presented with an eye-watering bill for the works, Farieda consulted her MP, Harriet Harman, and John Prescott, then deputy prime minister and the Communities Secretary.

There was a move to limit leaseholders’ liability in major works to £10,000, but it did not apply to Farieda.

Eric Pickles, the Conservative Communities Secretary, is now attempting to introduce this scheme. He was indignant at the case of local authority leaseholder Florence Bourne, 93, in Newham, north London, who died tormented by the fear that she would have to pay £50,000 towards the refurbishment of her block.

The proposal is that over a five-year period, local authority leaseholders will have a cap of £10,000 (£15,000 in London) for five years.

Of course, this scheme would not have assisted Farieda who has lived in her home since 1997.

Southwark is considering a scheme to offer to buy back ex-council flats from leaseholders who cannot afford to pay for the major works.

Timber at Kirwyn Way already looks in a parlous state
Timber at Kirwyn Way already looks in a parlous state

Inevitably, this gives rise to suspicions that Southwark will abuse its whip hand forced down prices before snapping them up.

In the case of Farieda Chandoo, there have been failings. She did need help, rather than being financially ruined. She did look into selling her flat back to the council or a housing association, but these solutions failed.

She is still bitter about the quality of the works: pointed to fractured masonry, rotting woodwork, rainwater accumulating on the flat roofs.

Damp pervades Kirwyn Way
Damp pervades Kirwyn Way

It is all too likely that Kirwyn Way will need another refurb at some point in the not too distant future.

The accommodation standards fall well short of the truly opulent council offices enjoyed by Southwark’s housing staff in Tooley Street, beside London Bridge.

We must hope that Farieda Chandoo is the last of Southwark’s leaseholders to suffer these sorts of losses in the courts.

Farieda Chandoo’s LVT ruling can be read here

 

 

Related posts:

George Osborne’s former nanny faces £100,000 bill and homelessness after refusing to pay major works on her leasehold ex-council flat George Osborne’s childhood nanny facing £115,000 bill to council Michelle Baharier Philip Rainey QCSouthwark litigant-in-person leaseholder faces wipe-out after £24,000 tribunal victory. Council now deploys ‘shock and awe’ QC … Florrie’s Law means new £15,000 cap on repair bills for council leasehold owners Oxford leaseholders win first round against £60,000 major works bills

Category: Forfeiture, HomeSlider, Local authority leasehold, News, Property tribunalTag: Farieda Chandoo, Forfeiture, George Osborne, Major works, Property tribunal, Section 20, Southwark

Latest Tweets

Tweets by @LKPleasehold

Mentions

Anthony Essien (34) APPG (37) ARMA (87) Bellway (30) Benjamin Mire (32) Cladding scandal (71) Clive Betts MP (31) CMA (45) Commonhold (52) Competition and Markets Authority (41) Countryside Properties plc (33) FirstPort (42) Grenfell cladding (56) Ground rents (54) Harry Scoffin (150) James Brokenshire MP (31) Jim Fitzpatrick (35) Jim Fitzpatrick MP (30) Justin Bates (40) Justin Madders MP (67) Katie Kendrick (37) Law Commission (60) LEASE (66) Leasehold Advisory Service (62) Leasehold houses (32) Long Harbour (48) Martin Boyd (80) McCarthy and Stone (39) National Leasehold Campaign (38) Persimmon (49) Peverel (61) Property tribunal (49) Redrow (30) Retirement (37) Robert Jenrick (33) Roger Southam (47) Sajid Javid (38) Sebastian O’Kelly (55) Sir Peter Bottomley (201) Taylor Wimpey (106) Tchenguiz (33) The Guardian (33) The Times (31) Vincent Tchenguiz (43) Waking watch contracts (40)
Previous Post: « Benjamin Mire has been in front of tribunal 52 times since 1999
Next Post: Collapsed ceilings and dripping walls at prime Timber Wharf in Manchester »

Above Footer

Advising leaseholders. Avoiding disasters.
Stopping forfeiture. Exposing abuses. Urging reform.

We depend on individuals for the majority of our funding.

Support Us and Donate

LKP Managing Agents

Become an LKP Managing Agent

Common Ground
Adam Church
Blocnet property management2

Stay in Touch

To achieve victory in the leasehold game where you are playing against professionals and with rules that they know all too well - stay informed with the LKP newsletter.
Sign Up for Newsletter

Professional Directory

The following advertisements are from firms that seek business from leaseholders.
Click on the logos for company profiles.

Footer

About LKP

  • What is LKP
  • Privacy and data

Categories

  • News
  • Cladding scandal
  • Commonhold
  • Law Commission
  • Fleecehold
  • Parliament
  • Press
  • APPG

Contact

Leasehold Knowledge Partnership
Open Data Institute
5th Floor
Kings Place
London N1 9AG

sok@leaseholdknowledge.com

Copyright © 2023 Leasehold Knowledge Partnership | All rights reserved
Leasehold Knowledge Partnership Limited (company number: 08999652) is a company limited by guarantee that is a registered charity (number: 1162584) with the Charities Commission.
LKP website is hosted at www.34sp.com
Website by Callia Web