Leasehold Knowledge Partnership

The registered charity for leaseholders

Menu
  • Home
    • Site map
    • Archive of posts by category
  • What is LKP
    • Privacy and Data Protection Statement
    • Site map
  • HELP FORM
  • News
      • APPG
      • ARMA
      • Bellway
      • Benjamin Mire
      • Brixton Hill Court
      • Canary Riverside
      • Charter Quay
      • Chelsea Bridge Wharf
      • Commonhold
      • Communities Select Committee
      • Conveyancing Association
      • Countrywide
      • DCLG
      • E&J Capital Partners
      • Exit fees
      • Fleecehold
      • Forfeiture
      • FPRA
      • Gleeson Homes
      • Ground rent scandal
      • Cladding crisis
      • Hanover
      • House managers flat
      • House of Lords
      • Housing associations
      • Informal lease extension
      • Insurance scams
      • IRPM
      • Jim Fitzpatrick MP
      • John Christodoulou
      • Justin Bates
      • Justin Madders MP
      • Law Commission
      • LEASE
      • Leasehold Valuation Tribunal
      • Local authority leasehold
      • London Assembly
      • Louie Burns
      • Martin Paine
      • McCarthy and Stone
      • Moskovitz / Gurvits
      • Mulberry Mews
      • National Leasehold Campaign
      • Oakland Court
      • OFT / CMA
      • Park Homes
      • Persimmon
      • Peverel
      • Philip Rainey QC
      • Plantation Wharf
      • Prostitutes
      • Quadrangle House
      • Recognised Tenants’ Association
      • Redrow
      • Retirement
      • RICS
      • Right To Manage Federation
      • Roger Southam
      • RTM
      • Sean Powell
      • SFO
      • Sinclair Gardens Investments
      • Sir Ed Davey
      • Sir Peter Bottomley
      • St George’s Wharf
      • Taylor Wimpey
      • Tchenguiz
      • West India Quay
      • William Waldorf Astor
      • Windrush Court
  • Accreditation
    • Accredited Companies
        • Block Managers Limited
        • Clear Building Management
        • Diamond Managing Agents
        • Dixon Emerald Associates
        • HML Group
        • Home from Home
        • Home Management Group
        • JFM Block & Estate Management
        • Jones Associates Letting & Management
        • Norwich Residential Management
        • Premier Block Management
        • Red Rock Property Management
        • Sapphire Property Management
        • Town & City Management
        • Urang Property Management
        • Vestra Property Management
  • Fighting back
      • Lease Extension
      • Q&As
      • Right to buy freehold
      • Commonhold
      • Bottomley blasts leasehold crimes on video
      • LVT/Property Chamber Survival
      • Tribunal triumphs … and defeats
      • Recognised Tenants’ Association
      • Right To Manage
      • Video
      • Find MP … and see how many leasehold voters
      • LEASE: what’s the point?
      • Pensioners win £68,500
      • Most damning LVT ruling ever made
      • Insurance racket
      • Local authority leasehold
      • Remember to extend your lease
      • St George’s wins £1 million
      • Leasehold law: the reforms
  • Sub-letting
  • Press
  • Contact
  • Parliament
      • Communities Select Committee
      • APPG
      • APPG December 14 2016
      • Commons Debate 20/12/16
      • APPG April 19 2017
      • APPG July 5 2017
      • APPG December 14 2016
  • Right To Manage
  • Lease Extension
  • National Leasehold Campaign
    • Louie Burns
    • Ground rent scandal
    • Michael Epstein
  • Donate
You are here: Home / Latest News / Court of Appeal turns down Mundy case – unanimously

Court of Appeal turns down Mundy case – unanimously

January 24, 2018 By admin

Chartered surveyor James Wyatt believes freeholders have been padding the costs of lease extensions by up to 50%. But his Parthenia mathematical model was rejected by the Court of Appeal today

The Court of Appeal has ruled against the Mundy case this morning.

In a unanimous ruling, the judges have also refused leave to appeal and awarded costs against Mundy, who was challenging the vested interests in leasehold with a statistically robust analysis of the untainted market evidence to value lease extensions and enfranchisement.

For leaseholders seeking to extend their leases, the ruling is a marked step in the wrong direction: the Parthenia model would have provided leaseholders with savings of up to 40 per cent.

In the view of LKP the set-back strengthens the argument for statutory imposed formula similar to those that exist in Northern Ireland and Scotland, whereby leaseholders can buy out the freehold for set multiple of annual ground rents.

Justin Madders MP has the second reading of his Bill to introduce precisely this measure next month. it is to be hoped that the government takes up the measure and it becomes law.

The Upper Tribunal of the property chamber had described Mr Wyatt’s Parthenia model as “a clock that struck 13”.

But the case did expose the flimsy methodology of all existing lease extension calculations – commissioned by vested interests in the leasehold sector.

But the case did expose the flimsy methodology of all existing lease extension calculations – commissioned by vested interests in the leasehold sector.

In his ruling, Lord Justice Lewison acknowledged that attempts to produce “the holy grail” – a definitive graph – by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors had failed.

Further, that the Gerald Eve – for years the sector standard – was commissioned by the Duke of Westminster’s Grosvenor Estate.

The property tribunal acknowledged its flaws.

Property tribunal upholds lease extension ‘scandal’ that pays millions to freeholders

James Wyatt said:

“The Gerald Eve curve, with no statistical methodology or sales evidence, has tainted the market and meant leaseholders have overpaid hundreds of millions and the taxpayers have paid tens of millions in unnecessary tribunal costs.

“The Parthenia model using 7,969 flat and house sales from the untainted market and is peer reviewed is dismissed because it contradicts the sale price of a flat influenced by the Gerald Eve curve.

“Our methodology was described in the Court of Appeal as an ‘inconvenient truth for the entire industry’, and the existing situation as being an unwarranted transfer of wealth from leaseholders to freeholders.

The problem for Parthenia is that while it may be more mathematically robust, it draws on data before the 1993 Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act, which changed the market by introducing enfranchisement.

In the succeeding 20 years, short leases have been transacted.

Lord Justice Lewison said:

“Sometimes markets behave irrationally. The tulip mania of the mid-17th century, the South Sea Bubble of the early 18 century, the railway mania of the mid 19-century and the dot.com bubble of the late 20th century are well known examples.

“Even in the absence of these extreme examples, markets are often influenced by what John Maynard Keynes called “animal spirits”.

“In my judgement there is no legal justification in a case like this for ignoring real market transactions.”

Court of Appeal Decision on Mundy

Related posts:

End lease extension ‘injustice’, veteran MP urges Commons Private Eye reports challenge to ‘scandal’ of lease extension values Default ThumbnailCourt of Appeal ruling on Mundy case’s ‘inconvenient truth’ expected on Wednesday Court of Appeal to hear Mundy case which will save millions on lease extensions Mundy case in Court of Appeal showdown over valuation racket

Filed Under: Latest News, News Tagged With: Court of Appeal, Gerald Eve, James Wyatt, Lord Justice Lewison, Parthenia

Contact LKP

Need help?

LKPhelp2The leasehold game is weighted against ordinary home-owning leaseholders, who aren’t professional players. LKP was set up to redress the balance, to help you win your disputes or at least avoid disasters.

If you have a leasehold problem, you can email sok@leaseholdknowledge or take a chance on calling 07808 328 230.

Or fill out this form, which ensures that you provide the essential information.

LKPnewsletter3

Professional services

The following advertisements are from firms that seek business from leaseholders. Click on the logos for company profiles.

Law

Right to manage

Lease extension / enfranchisement


capitalleasehold6-9ins

Insurance

Landscaping

limetree

LKP Managing Agents

Big managing agents are big because they have got business from developers or large-scale freehold owing companies. Doubtless they are very obliging.

Not a single one is big through consumer choice.

Managing agents accredited to LKP want business from leaseholders. Many are former leaseholders.

All have signed undertakings of good practice and have provided extensive references … from leaseholders.

They can also hand-hold leaseholders through right to manage at minimal cost.

Contact Sebastian O’Kelly at LKP for further details: sok@leaseholdknowledge.com, 07808 328 230

Please click on logos for link and details

Comments

  1. stephen says

    January 24, 2018 at 1:18 pm

    There really should be a defined table of relativity to apply to all flats except possibly those in Council Tax bands G & H where the term remaining is say in excess of 60 years.

    The amount of variation in marriage value within those permaters is relatively modest but is dwarfed by professional fees that the lessee has to incur

    The Gerald Eve graph which has been used to date and supported in legal cases, such as this should now perhaps be formally adopted into the legislation

    In Capital Gains tax legislation there is a table for wasting assets so the idea would not be new

  2. fleecehold reform says

    January 24, 2018 at 2:22 pm

    disappointing though hardly surprising. And about time we abolished the leasehold system altogether, this is the priority now.

  3. Doubler says

    January 24, 2018 at 2:41 pm

    Not surprised one bit, the vested interests of “England PLC” has won again!

  4. Brad says

    January 24, 2018 at 3:07 pm

    Not surprised. Just look at the volume of the UK’s elite, elected and unelected decision makers with a vested interest in land.

    If you haven’t seen it and have a strong enough disposition, I recommend reading a blog called ‘who owns England’.

    Loses like this will hopefully make the various campaigns stronger.

  5. Kim says

    January 24, 2018 at 3:08 pm

    At least he had the cojones to challenge the status quo. It is a pity that he states he is “ wiped out financially “however he seems a very bright chap and I’m sure he will “ live long and prosper”. I believe that this verdict will just strengthen the resolve of campaigners who are demanding the Abolition of Leasehold and Strict Regulation of Managing Agents.

    The online petition is rapidly heading towards 7’000 . Please sign and share

  6. Michael Epstein says

    January 24, 2018 at 4:39 pm

    Try and be positive folks,
    Our campaign is bound to have setbacks along the road. The trick is to move on and turn a defeat into an ultimate victory.
    Had we won, appeals would have been made up to the highest courts in the land, over a long period of time, at great expense and with no guarantee the victory wouldn’t be overturned. At best, all a ruling in our favour could have done is to mitigate one of the worst excesses of leasehold.
    This is yet another string to our bow that goes to prove leasehold does not work. it does not need “Mitigating” It needs “Abolishing!”

    • Kim says

      January 24, 2018 at 6:49 pm

      Wise words Master Epstein.

  7. Paddy says

    January 24, 2018 at 5:43 pm

    Not being funny as Tracy Pritchard on BBC’s W1A was wont to say, but I think I said this would happen.

    After watching the S of S from the new ‘Ministry of Moral Indignation On Housing Matters’ on Monday tell Parliament along the lines that, whatever the legal position, he argued the moral position in respect of freeholders being liable for cladding costs, I admit I had a funny feeling. The issues all somehow meld together? Not being funny or anything.

    • Kim says

      January 24, 2018 at 6:38 pm

      In keeping with the W1A analogy . As the hilarious Marketing guru Siobhan Sharpe would have said to M’ learned friends at the appeal hearing:

      “ I am totally listening… what is is , you guys aren’t saying the right stuff.”

  8. Dennis says

    January 25, 2018 at 1:17 am

    Janes Wyatt legal bill could be of the order of £500,000 I possibly more

    2.1 million leaseholders have leases below 80 years as a way of saying “thank you” for trying if each gave just 25p – it would have him from financial ruin

    I am sure some of the younger people would know how to set up a web page to achieve this

    • fleecehold reform says

      January 25, 2018 at 2:23 pm

      I am with you on this. It is important to show solidarity and demonstrate strength in numbers.

      Sadly though, the average leaseholder will have no idea of what is going on, what is marriage value and why they need a lease extension. A lot of people I spoke with hardly know what is the length of their lease – until its too late. There are complex issues and many flat owners think they will sell and move on long before there is a problem.

      LKP makes these issues more widely known, but otherwise ‘vested interests ‘ (freeholders, managing agents, dodgy lawyers, ) much prefer a flock of ignorant leaseholders, who do not understand the law or know their rights.

  9. Joe says

    January 25, 2018 at 10:43 am

    Tchenguiz,Roger Southam, Dukes of Westminster, Will Astor, Mr Fook MP and anonymous freeholders based in offshore tax havens will be celebrating big time.

    Property law once again fails to protect the ordinary leaseholder but favours billionaire investors.

    2.1 leaseholders all have votes and should use them at the next election to support the party which offers bold change and consumer protection.

    It is realistic and not defeatist to say that Theresa May and Javid have no intention of abolishing leasehold. They don’t even back the idea of a Regulator to protect the consumer against blatant overcharging. Consumer protection is one of their big ideas but sadly little sign of it in the property world. Vested interests of the property lobby dictate government policy and that shows no sign of changing

    • fleecehod reform says

      January 25, 2018 at 2:33 pm

      Sadly I have to agree with you. Theresa May will not instigate any meaningful reform. This government will leave it up to the ‘goodwill’ of the the freeholder to do ‘the right thing’ and other platitudes. I had to sit through and listen to her talk about plastics which basically said ‘everyone should recycle more and buy less plastic’. No legislation, no enforcement, no penalties. Nothing.

      We need radical reform not soothing words.

      • Paddy says

        January 26, 2018 at 10:04 am

        Somewhat like the Secretary of State of the new Ministry of Housing etc answering questions last Monday sounding quite firmly indignant that, whatever the legal position, he used the moral argument that freeholders should pay for removing unsafe cladding.

        The questioner appeared bewildered at this answer from the government.

        Quite. We seem to live in an era of government nannying and platitudes that sound cuddly and caring but come without any legal clout.

        Neither the courts or freeholders or managing agents are quaking at indignant sound bites. All that matters is law.

        We don’t elect representative nannies.

        Why is it so hard to publish ANY component of leasehold reform in a government bill to date?

        It took no time at all to announce to the managing agents without any evidence presented that the majority were ‘good guys’.

        I have yet to meet any of them myself after 20 years.

        Meanwhile I thought I heard a minister promise to meet Justin Madders in the new year about his bill. Wonder if that happened?

LKPnewsletter3

Tweets by @LKPleasehold

Essential reads

  • Sir Peter Bottomley
  • Martin Paine
  • Roger Southam
  • LKP full archive
  • Most damning LVT ruling ever made
  • Pensioners win £68,500
  • Benjamin Mire
  • Moskovitz / Gurvits
  • Plantation Wharf
  • Peverel Cirrus story so far
  • Sean Powell
  • Tchenguiz
  • West India Quay
  • Essential guide to lease extensions
  • Forfeiture
  • Press
  • Right to manage and taking control

News archive

Leaseholders and freeholder of evacuated Manchester block win £10.8m insurer payout for ‘serious defects’

By Harry Scoffin A freeholder and his leaseholders secured victory at the Court of Appeal last week, with the insurer ordered to pay a £10.8m bill for works to make a Manchester development safe. Although the faults pre-date Grenfell, it is the first court case win for private leaseholders over safety and structural defects since […]

Donations to LKP will be doubled by PayPal through December (up to £1,000 per donor)

LKP moved its charitable donation provider in the summer when BTdonate came to an end. We now only use PayPal as a portal. You can make a donation here We do so as many other charitable payment portals charge quite high fees. Throughout December PayPal is prepared to match any donation to LKP up to […]

Leaseholder of £3m pad in central London demands £100 a day off Gerald Ronson for no internet  

By Harry Scoffin A millionaire travel tycoon has marched his freeholder to court over a failure to provide internet to his luxury flat in The Heron, Barbican. Stephen Shalson, 70, moved into the apartment in London’s Square Mile in February 2014 and claims he had to endure “about a thousand days” of non-service. He says […]

Cladding site? Come to parliamentary meeting on January 9 … and get your MP to attend as well

[The response form had a glitch. Now fixed] By Sebastian O’Kelly LKP director The Leasehold Knowledge Partnership is holding a parliamentary meeting at Westminster on January 9 at 5pm to address the cladding crisis. It is clear to LKP – and should be to officials and ministers – that thousands of flat owners living in […]

LKP trustee Professor James Driscoll dies

LKP sadly announces the death of one of its trustees, Professor James Driscoll. James was a solicitor, an academic, an author and a mediator. For eleven years he sat as a judge on the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber). Siobhan McGrath, President of the Property Chamber said that “James had been a talented and popular Judge […]

Does Li Ka-shing own your Adriatic freehold, or Hutchison Whampoa, or billionaire Frank Sixt, or Astor? Only Long Harbour knows, and it’s not saying …

The secretive Long Harbour fund came under further scrutiny today, with an article in The Times on leasehold house owners in the north-west mounting a collective challenge for their freeholds. But who owns these freeholds, where the beneficial ownership is hidden behind nominee directors of a company secretary group headquartered in Jersey? Families challenge Long […]

Families challenge Long Harbour for freeholds to Bellway leasehold houses, The Times reports

Seventy families in Ellesmere Port in Cheshire are locked in a battle to gain the freeholds to their Bellway homes that were sold off to William Waldorf Astor’s secretive Long Harbour fund, The Times reports today. Katie Kendrick, co-founder of the National Leasehold Campaign and LKP trustee, has organised her neighbours to demand the freeholds. […]

Cladding victims now being hit by insurance hikes, reports BBC R4 You and Yours

By Harry Scoffin The cladding crisis has rippled through the insurance market, with leasehold tenants in dangerous apartment buildings “being hammered” by “inflated bills”, BBC Radio 4’s You and Yours programme was told yesterday. Lessees of flats in Birmingham’s Islington Gates, a mixed-use development with 144 properties wrapped in Grenfell ACM (aluminium composite material), claim […]

Grenfell United link up with leaseholder groups to protest cladding crisis and warn next government of Grenfell 2

By Harry Scoffin Survivors of the Grenfell Tower fire have this week joined forces with leaseholders stuck in privately-owned blocks clad with deadly combustibles, telling the major party leaders of their “deep and grave concern that a Grenfell-like fire is going to occur again”. In a letter sent on Tuesday to Boris Johnson, Jeremy Corbyn […]

Martin Lewis, the Money Saving Expert, challenges party leaders over leasehold scandal

By Harry Scoffin Consumer affairs champion Martin Lewis (above) has challenged the major party leaders to explain their policies on leasehold as part of an online election debate. Election 2019: The MSE Leaders’ Debate It’s the biggest consumer decision most will make in 2019. While it’s important to factor everything in, voting to choose who […]

Would you want your former Prudential pension invested in Tchenguiz ground rents by Rothesay Life? FT reports concerns

The Financial Times has reported concerns about pensions invested by Rothesay Life in the ground rent portfolio of Vincent Tchenguiz. Rothesay Life has loans of some £1.7bn to the Tchenguiz interests, which are secured against ground rents that are paid annually by residential leaseholders. UK regulator under fire over £12bn annuity deal The UK’s Prudential […]

Why AN14 is making your cladding flat impossible to sell

By Martin Boyd A growing number of leaseholders are discovering that selling their flat has become more difficult. Prospective buyers need to obtain a valuation for their lenders. Now, on thousands of homes, this may mean they need something called an ‘Advice Note 14’ (AN14) report and it many cases these reports do not exist! […]

Supreme Court blocks enfranchisement ploy that seems to be pure enrichment

The legal somersault that is lease enfranchisement – the right of a private individual compulsorily to acquire the property (the freehold) of someone else – has come under the scrutiny of the Supreme Court. Hautford Limited owned the lease of a six storey building, which could be either residential or commercial depending on the consent […]

‘You weren’t mis-sold your leasehold house and I am keeping my £45m bonus’, is the message of Persimmon CEO to Bluebell Meadow

Persimmon fatcat says he isn’t going to hand over freeholds at Bluebell Meadow … Even though taxpayers through Help To Buy subsidised these flawed purchases, which also helped make him a multimillionaire Persimmon CEO David Jenkinson, who received a controversial bonus of £45 million which saw his predecessor sacked, has said he will not be […]

Taxpayers funding two leasehold houses a day in 2019 through Help To Buy … despite government saying THREE times they should be banned

By Harry Scoffin Almost two years on from the announcement of a ban on the sale of new-build houses as leasehold tenancies, developers are continuing to cash in on the practice. According to government figures published yesterday, the first half of 2019 has seen Help To Buy equity loans taken out on 395 leasehold houses. […]

Retirement housebuilders will only reform when they are forced to do so, Lord Best tells property conference

By Harry Scoffin Influential crossbench peer Lord Richard Best told the Homes UK conference in London’s Excel centre yesterday that retirement housebuilders need to up their game following devastating reports last week in both The Times and The Guardian. Both newspapers drew on the work of LKP’s sister organisation www.BetterRetirementHousing.com to condemn dismal resale values […]

Developers can now seize FREEHOLD homes, reports BBC R4 MoneyBox in shocking expose of ‘fleecehold’

By Harry Scoffin Tens of thousands of consumer homeowners face having their freehold houses taken off them by developers if they “fall more than 40 days behind” on estate management payments, an investigation by BBC Radio 4’s MoneyBox has found. MoneyBox reported on Saturday that the number of houses subject to restrictive ‘rentcharges’ and estate […]

Only one Grenfell cladding site in line for taxpayer handout as December 31st deadline looms, reports BBC R4 You and Yours  

By Harry Scoffin Six months on from the government declaring that taxpayers would pay to save leaseholders from ruinous Grenfell ACM cladding bills, only 1 of the 86 sites has got to the first approval stage ahead of the December 31 deadline. Despite this dismal level of progress, a Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local […]

The Liberals (no, not those ones) register ‘severe dissatisfaction’ with Tory record on leasehold

By Harry Scoffin The Liberals, once the Conservatives’ main rival in British politics and the party of government during the late 18th and early 19th centuries, have launched a blistering broadside at the Tories over leasehold inaction in its 2019 election offering. The minor party, which opposed the 1988 merger between the Liberals and the […]

‘Get leasehold done’? Boris Johnson’s Conservatives repeat 2017 pledges in manifesto

By Harry Scoffin The Conservative party will implement plans to ban the selling of houses as leasehold tenancies and slash new ground rents to zero, it was confirmed today. The policies feature in the 60-page manifesto entitled “Get Brexit Done, Unleash Britain’s Potential”, launched this afternoon in the marginal seat of Telford. On page 29 […]

More Posts from this Category

DIrection

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Find Everything

Essential reads …

  • Ground rent scandal
  • Parliament
  • MPs’ APPG on leasehold
  • Benjamin Mire
  • Moskovitz / Gurvits
  • Oakland Court
  • McCarthy and Stone
  • Persimmon
  • Recognised Tenants’ Association
  • Cladding crisis
  • Canary Riverside
  • John Christodoulou
  • Peverel
  • Peverel Cirrus story so far
  • Charter Quay
  • Forfeiture
  • Plantation Wharf
  • Law Commission
  • Plantation Wharf
  • West India Quay
  • LEASE: what’s the point?
  • Tchenguiz
  • Sean Powell
  • Press
  • Exit fees
  • William Waldorf Astor
  • Martin Paine
  • LKP anthem
  • LVT/Property Chamber Survival
  • Most damning LVT ruling ever made
  • Pensioners win £68,500
  • Park Homes
  • Redrow
  • Retirement

Copyright © 2019 Leasehold Knowledge Partnership