• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Home
  • What is LKP
  • Find everything …
  • Contact
Donate

Leasehold Knowledge Management Logo

Secretariat of the All Party Parliamentary Group on leasehold reform

Mobile Menu

  • Home
  • What is LKP
  • Find everything …
  • Contact
  • Advice
  • News
    • Find everything …
    • About Peverel group
    • APPG
    • ARMA
    • Bellway
    • Benjamin Mire
    • Brixton Hill Court
    • Canary Riverside
    • Charter Quay
    • Chelsea Bridge Wharf
    • Cladding scandal
    • Competition and Markets Authority / OFT
    • Commonhold
    • Communities Select Committee
    • Conveyancing Association
    • Countrywide
    • MHCLG
    • E&J Capital Partners
    • Exit fees
    • FirstPort
    • Fleecehold
    • Forfeiture
    • FPRA
    • Gleeson Homes
    • Ground rent scandal
    • Hanover
    • House managers flat
    • House of Lords
    • Housing associations
    • Informal lease extension
    • Insurance
    • IRPM
    • Jim Fitzpatrick MP
    • John Christodoulou
    • Justin Bates
    • Justin Madders MP
    • Law Commission
    • LEASE
    • Liam Spender
    • Local authority leasehold
    • London Assembly
    • Louie Burns
    • Martin Paine
    • McCarthy and Stone
    • Michael Epstein
    • Moskovitz / Gurvits
    • Mulberry Mews
    • National Leasehold Campaign
    • Oakland Court
    • Park Homes
    • Parliament
    • Persimmon
    • Peverel
    • Philip Rainey QC
    • Plantation Wharf
    • Press
    • Property tribunal
    • Prostitutes
    • Quadrangle House
    • Redrow
    • Retirement
    • Richard Davidoff
    • RICS
    • Right To Manage Federation
    • Roger Southam
    • Rooftop development
    • RTM
    • Sean Powell
    • SFO
    • Shared ownership
    • Sinclair Gardens Investments
    • Sir Ed Davey
    • Sir Peter Bottomley
    • St George’s Wharf
    • Subletting
    • Taylor Wimpey
    • Tchenguiz
    • Warwick Estates
    • West India Quay
    • William Waldorf Astor
    • Windrush Court
  • Parliament
  • Accreditation
  • [Custom]
Menu
  • Advice
  • News
      • Find everything …
      • About Peverel group
      • APPG
      • ARMA
      • Bellway
      • Benjamin Mire
      • Brixton Hill Court
      • Canary Riverside
      • Charter Quay
      • Chelsea Bridge Wharf
      • Cladding scandal
      • Competition and Markets Authority / OFT
      • Commonhold
      • Communities Select Committee
      • Conveyancing Association
      • Countrywide
      • MHCLG
      • E&J Capital Partners
      • Exit fees
      • FirstPort
      • Fleecehold
      • Forfeiture
      • FPRA
      • Gleeson Homes
      • Ground rent scandal
      • Hanover
      • House managers flat
      • House of Lords
      • Housing associations
      • Informal lease extension
      • Insurance
      • IRPM
      • Jim Fitzpatrick MP
      • John Christodoulou
      • Justin Bates
      • Justin Madders MP
      • Law Commission
      • LEASE
      • Liam Spender
      • Local authority leasehold
      • London Assembly
      • Louie Burns
      • Martin Paine
      • McCarthy and Stone
      • Michael Epstein
      • Moskovitz / Gurvits
      • Mulberry Mews
      • National Leasehold Campaign
      • Oakland Court
      • Park Homes
      • Parliament
      • Persimmon
      • Peverel
      • Philip Rainey QC
      • Plantation Wharf
      • Press
      • Property tribunal
      • Prostitutes
      • Quadrangle House
      • Redrow
      • Retirement
      • Richard Davidoff
      • RICS
      • Right To Manage Federation
      • Roger Southam
      • Rooftop development
      • RTM
      • Sean Powell
      • SFO
      • Shared ownership
      • Sinclair Gardens Investments
      • Sir Ed Davey
      • Sir Peter Bottomley
      • St George’s Wharf
      • Subletting
      • Taylor Wimpey
      • Tchenguiz
      • Warwick Estates
      • West India Quay
      • William Waldorf Astor
      • Windrush Court
  • Parliament
  • Accreditation
You are here: Home / Commonhold / Here’s commonhold, but it won’t be mandatory. Shula Rich recalls the compromises behind the 2002 Act

Here’s commonhold, but it won’t be mandatory. Shula Rich recalls the compromises behind the 2002 Act

March 20, 2020 //  by Harry Scoffin

Shula Rich is a veteran leasehold reformer, and vice chair of the Federation of Private Residents’ Association, who runs a drop-in advice service for leaseholders in Brighton. She was on the Lord Chancellor’s working party to introduce commonhold in the 2002 Act

Making commonhold the mandatory form of communal tenure was undermined in a deal with the sector, veteran leasehold activist Shula Rich told the Westminster Legal Policy Forum conference on March 12.

Ms Rich, speaking as vice chair of the Federation of Private Residents’ Association, told the meeting in central London that New Labour had been elected in 1997 on a manifesto pledge to implement commonhold ownership.

It said: “For new developments, this will provide a complete answer to many of the problems which have plagued flat-owners over the decades.”

Ms Rich was a member of the working group on commonhold set up by the Lord Chancellor, which drew on “An End to Feudalism”, a Labour policy document from October 1995.

“Commonhold should be mandatory [on new-build flats], we should have introduced a sunset clause on leasehold and we haven’t. So why haven’t we? Why is there no sunset clause on leasehold?

“On that commonhold working party, we had representatives of all stakeholders and at that time, the representative of the British Property Federation, who is now a representative of the National Landlords Association, said: ‘If you make commonhold mandatory, if you introduce a sunset clause on leasehold, the British Property Federation won’t support it.’

“So the well-known leasehold organisation that was minuting the proceedings said: ‘Oh well, in that case we won’t have it.’

“Later in 2001, Lord [Charles] Falconer, who was minister of housing, said to us all at a Labour party fringe meeting: ‘As you know, the 2002 Act was the result of a bargain.’

“And that was the bargain: we would have commonhold, but we would not make it mandatory.”

Ms Rich continues to believe in commonhold, but has concerns about its introduction into a housing sector where there are 5-6 million leasehold properties.

“Why do I believe we should have commonhold? The reason is that leasehold is the epitome of institutionalised inequality. Political parties agree that the system is feudal, but have done nothing more about it.”

She concurred with Nigel Glen, CEO of the Association of Residential Managing Agents, who also spoke at the Westminster Legal Policy Forum event, that a shift to commonhold would impact the property values of existing leaseholders, as leasehold becomes less attractive to consumer homebuyers:

“One big argument against making commonhold mandatory – which I can’t help but agree with – is that we do not want to create a second-class tenure in leasehold.

“If there are already 5 million leaseholds, can we fairly devalue it? I don’t think we can.”

But transitioning to a commonhold world could be done in a way that alleviates leaseholders who may be unable to buy out their landlord and trade up to the superior tenure, Ms Rich suggested.

Echoing the LKP view, the veteran campaigner said that government could take concerted action to strip out the unfair income streams, such as hidden insurance commissions. This would drive freehold speculators out of the market and guard against major property devaluation of the existing leasehold stock.

“What we can do is improve leasehold as an alternative to commonhold so that those remaining leaseholds will provide a viable alternative and still be saleable.”

In June 2014, the British Property Federation finally conceded the need for a more muscular approach to mainstreaming commonhold.

Speaking at an LKP-organised parliamentary event, a spokesperson said the organisation would accept a need for a sunset clause on leasehold – after being shown that the commonhold legislation was now working.

Related posts:

Housebuilders WILL benefit from commonhold, Hopton Build developer tells Law Commission Time to have another look at commonhold, say Lords. But what are Lord Best’s proposals? LKP holds Westminster meeting on commonhold Leaseholders and the sector react to Law Commission reforms to commonhold and right to manage Nigel Glen commonholdARMA on commonhold: Falling leasehold values. Zombie apartment blocks. Plenty of scrapping. Lack of interest. But good business for professional managers …

Category: Commonhold, FPRA, Latest News, NewsTag: 2002 Act, Commonhold, Lord Falconer, Shula Rich, Westminster Legal Policy Forum

Latest Tweets

Tweets by @LKPleasehold

Mentions

Anthony Essien (34) APPG (36) ARMA (86) Bellway (30) Benjamin Mire (32) Cladding scandal (70) Clive Betts MP (31) CMA (41) Commonhold (49) Competition and Markets Authority (37) Countryside Properties plc (32) FirstPort (37) Forfeiture (29) Grenfell cladding (55) Ground rents (51) James Brokenshire MP (31) Jim Fitzpatrick (35) Jim Fitzpatrick MP (30) Justin Bates (38) Justin Madders MP (62) Katie Kendrick (35) Law Commission (59) LEASE (66) Leasehold Advisory Service (62) Leasehold houses (32) Long Harbour (44) Martin Boyd (77) McCarthy and Stone (39) National Leasehold Campaign (38) Persimmon (49) Peverel (61) Property tribunal (48) Redrow (29) Retirement (37) Robert Jenrick (33) Roger Southam (47) Sajid Javid (38) Sebastian O’Kelly (55) Sir Peter Bottomley (196) Taylor Wimpey (104) Tchenguiz (33) The Guardian (32) The Times (30) Vincent Tchenguiz (40) Waking watch contracts (40)
Previous Post: «Helen Hayes leasehold Southwark announces new bills … and no funds for leaseholder group
Next Post: Buildings ‘just below 18m’ included in cladding fund »

Above Footer

Advising leaseholders. Avoiding disasters.
Stopping forfeiture. Exposing abuses. Urging reform.

We depend on individuals for the majority of our funding.

Support Us and Donate

LKP Managing Agents

Become an LKP Managing Agent

Common Ground
Adam Church
Blocnet property management2

Stay in Touch

To achieve victory in the leasehold game where you are playing against professionals and with rules that they know all too well - stay informed with the LKP newsletter.
Sign Up for Newsletter

Professional Directory

The following advertisements are from firms that seek business from leaseholders.
Click on the logos for company profiles.

Footer

About LKP

  • What is LKP
  • Privacy and data

Categories

  • News
  • Cladding scandal
  • Commonhold
  • Law Commission
  • Fleecehold
  • Parliament
  • Press
  • APPG

Contact

Leasehold Knowledge Partnership
Open Data Institute
5th Floor
Kings Place
London N1 9AG

sok@leaseholdknowledge.com

Copyright © 2022 Leasehold Knowledge Partnership | All rights reserved
Leasehold Knowledge Partnership Limited (company number: 08999652) is a company limited by guarantee that is a registered charity (number: 1162584) with the Charities Commission.
LKP website is hosted at no charge by www.34sp.com
Website by Callia Web